# Player Voice Audit — Ys X: Nordics

생성일: 2026-08-09 · 대상 기간: 2024-10-25 ~ 2026-08-06

## 개요

- 게임: **Ys X: Nordics** (Nihon Falcom, PH3 GmbH) · Steam appid 2731870
- Steam 전체 평가: **Mostly Positive** (긍정 729 / 부정 222 / 전체 951)
- 분석 수집분: 리뷰 329건, 부정 151건 (46%)

## 감성 트렌드

- 최근 30일 평균 감성: **0.23** (−1 ~ +1)
- 이전 기간 대비: +0.13 (개선)

## 토픽별 감성

| 토픽 | 언급 수 | 부정 언급 | 부정률 |
|---|---:|---:|---:|
| 기타 | 171 | 64 | 37% |
| 스토리·서사 | 96 | 41 | 43% |
| 콘텐츠 분량 | 66 | 51 | 77% |
| 그래픽·사운드 | 41 | 15 | 37% |
| 멀티플레이·네트워크 | 23 | 11 | 48% |
| 난이도 | 18 | 8 | 44% |
| 성능·최적화 | 16 | 4 | 25% |
| UI·UX | 12 | 6 | 50% |

## 언어 분포

- english: 247건 (75%)
- japanese: 28건 (9%)
- french: 15건 (5%)
- schinese: 7건 (2%)
- russian: 7건 (2%)
- german: 6건 (2%)
- brazilian: 5건 (2%)
- spanish: 4건 (1%)
- polish: 3건 (1%)
- italian: 2건 (1%)

## 이상 이벤트 (부정 리뷰 스파이크)

- **2026-02-20**: 부정 리뷰 15건 — 인접 공지: "Критики оценили выше оригинала: Состоялся релиз Ys X: Proud Nordics"
- **2026-02-21**: 부정 리뷰 9건 — 인접 공지: "Критики оценили выше оригинала: Состоялся релиз Ys X: Proud Nordics"

## 대표 부정 피드백 발췌

**콘텐츠 분량** (schinese, 2026-08-01)
> what kind of garbage dlc is this?

**기타** (japanese, 2026-07-09)
> 完全版商法を始めたので評価を下げます。

**스토리·서사** (english, 2026-02-22)
> You know exactly why im writing this review. Thew fact that the upgrade is time gated and not offered straight to loyal fans who have already bought the game once is absolutely disgusting. Punishing your biggest fans who buys your games on launch day is exactly what you shouldnt…

**성능·최적화** (english, 2026-02-21)
> Amazing game, but I can't recommend buying this edition, since Proud Nordics came out. Proud Nordics includes all of the content, but includes an additional patch for performance, quality of life, and a new dungeon area. If you bought this version of the game, you got screwed, a…

**밸런스·게임플레이** (english, 2026-02-21)
> I already finish this game long before Ys X proud nordic announced and never skip any Falcom game before but this need to stop , NIS america and Falcom release proud nordic at an definition edition but to be honest all of the change should be a dlc or a balance patch not a full …

원본 리뷰: https://steamcommunity.com/app/2731870/reviews/

## 우선 대응 권고 (액션 아이템)

신뢰도 가중(리뷰 작성 시점 플레이타임)과 최근성을 반영한 우선순위입니다.

| 우선순위 | 영역 | 부정 언급 | 20시간+ 플레이어 | 최근 30일 | 점수 |
|---|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| P0 | 콘텐츠 분량 | 51건 | 76% | 2% | 5.8 |
| P2 | 버그·안정성 | 6건 | 83% | 0% | 1.2 |
| P2 | 난이도 | 8건 | 75% | 0% | 1 |
| P2 | 스토리·서사 | 41건 | 71% | 0% | 0.9 |
| P2 | 멀티플레이·네트워크 | 11건 | 64% | 0% | 0.5 |
| P2 | 밸런스·게임플레이 | 7건 | 86% | 0% | 0.4 |

**P0 · 콘텐츠 분량** — 베테랑 플레이어 비중 76%
> I love YS, I love Falcom, but how they handled the Proud Nordics DLC was just plain scummy. I am not buying this again lol
> Don't be tricked like to buying this version like the rest of us. This is an obsolete version. This version has less content, can't be upgraded and cost same as proud.

**P2 · 버그·안정성** — 베테랑 플레이어 비중 83%
> TLDR: This is not deserving of a $60 price tag (I'd say $30-$40). No wonder they're doing a remake of it. I felt the story was fine but several gameplay mechanics make this a very much suffering experience. While I normally try to be pretty forgiving, there's unfortunately a lot …
> I finally came around playing this one. It is clear what they're trying to do: the recreation of YS 8, probably one of the best action games I've ever played. They succeeded for the most part. YS games have an unique charm to them where you truly feel like you're going on an adve…

**P2 · 난이도** — 베테랑 플레이어 비중 75%
> Decent addition to the Ys franchise. Story not as compelling as in Ys 9 or 8. Gameplay is better, but speed attacks are too easy to dodge. Looking forward to the next game and gameplay improvements. Do not buy this version of the game, buy proud.
> A better, more complete version was announced 1 month after this game got released with the English localization. I find it very scummy. Buy the Proud Nordics edition instead, but only at a discount as this game unfortunately lacks in content and feels somewhat repetitive at time…

※ 이 표는 Jira/Linear 임포트용 CSV로도 제공됩니다 (대시보드 → 액션 CSV).

## 방법론

- 데이터: Steam 공개 리뷰 (appreviews 엔드포인트, 증분 수집)
- 감성/토픽: Claude 분석기 또는 휴리스틱 폴백, analyzer_version으로 추적
- 액션 우선순위: 부정 언급 볼륨 × 신뢰도 가중(플레이타임 로그 스케일) × 최근성(반감기 45일)
- 작성자 정보는 수집 시 가명처리되며 본 리포트에 포함되지 않음
- 발췌는 저작권 고려로 280자 이내로 제한, 원본 링크 제공