# Player Voice Audit — Trails in the Sky 1st Chapter

생성일: 2026-08-09 · 대상 기간: 2025-09-19 ~ 2026-08-09

## 개요

- 게임: **Trails in the Sky 1st Chapter** (Nihon Falcom) · Steam appid 3375780
- Steam 전체 평가: **Overwhelmingly Positive** (긍정 4392 / 부정 205 / 전체 4597)
- 분석 수집분: 리뷰 309건, 부정 27건 (9%)

## 감성 트렌드

- 최근 30일 평균 감성: **0.57** (−1 ~ +1)
- 이전 기간 대비: +0.21 (개선)

## 토픽별 감성

| 토픽 | 언급 수 | 부정 언급 | 부정률 |
|---|---:|---:|---:|
| 기타 | 185 | 17 | 9% |
| 스토리·서사 | 107 | 8 | 7% |
| 그래픽·사운드 | 43 | 3 | 7% |
| 멀티플레이·네트워크 | 15 | 2 | 13% |
| 밸런스·게임플레이 | 14 | 4 | 29% |
| 콘텐츠 분량 | 8 | 1 | 13% |
| 난이도 | 7 | 1 | 14% |
| UI·UX | 7 | 1 | 14% |

## 언어 분포

- english: 200건 (65%)
- russian: 31건 (10%)
- japanese: 19건 (6%)
- spanish: 14건 (5%)
- brazilian: 12건 (4%)
- french: 8건 (3%)
- latam: 7건 (2%)
- german: 7건 (2%)
- thai: 3건 (1%)
- swedish: 2건 (1%)

## 이상 이벤트 (부정 리뷰 스파이크)

- 감지된 스파이크 없음

## 대표 부정 피드백 발췌

**기타** (russian, 2026-08-07)
> Самое лучшее в этой игре - это финал. Потому что это говно закончилось. ДедПи дерьмо распиарил.

**스토리·서사** (english, 2026-07-28)
> Long-winded tedious and boring "story", where only the last hour of gameplay has any meat on it. I guess part 2, is where the story of the game is contained

**밸런스·게임플레이** (spanish, 2026-07-26)
> At first it was kinda fine, y'know typical JRPG, then they story starts to be interesting, but then it takes a brief stop for some ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥, then it continues and then stops again and you are doing a theatre play. it has a very bad pacing, the enemies have too much health and co…

**콘텐츠 분량** (brazilian, 2026-07-23)
> o jogo tinha tudo para ser maravilhoso, mas achei ele irritante! Primeiro que os personagens têm só uma roupa durante o jogo inteiro. para eu conseguir outra roupa eu tenho que ficar comprando dlc, o que eu acho um absurdo e um falta de consideração com o consumidor, porque o jo…

**버그·안정성** (english, 2026-07-18)
> Trails in the Sky is the first entry in Falcom’s beloved turn-based RPG series. The story follows siblings (and eventual lovers) Estelle and Joshua Bright as they begin their journey as junior bracers, inspired by their legendary father Cassius Bright. The narrative is a slow bu…

원본 리뷰: https://steamcommunity.com/app/3375780/reviews/

## 우선 대응 권고 (액션 아이템)

신뢰도 가중(리뷰 작성 시점 플레이타임)과 최근성을 반영한 우선순위입니다.

| 우선순위 | 영역 | 부정 언급 | 20시간+ 플레이어 | 최근 30일 | 점수 |
|---|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| P0 | 스토리·서사 | 8건 | 63% | 100% | 9.9 |
| P1 | 밸런스·게임플레이 | 4건 | 75% | 100% | 5.2 |
| P1 | 그래픽·사운드 | 3건 | 33% | 100% | 3.2 |

**P0 · 스토리·서사** — 베테랑 플레이어 비중 63%
> Long-winded tedious and boring "story", where only the last hour of gameplay has any meat on it. I guess part 2, is where the story of the game is contained
> Story - OK Charaktere - langweilig, kindisch Gameplay - repetitiv Spaß - eher nicht Eigentlich habe ich es immer nur gestartet, um schnell eine Quest zu erledigen und wieder rauszuspringen, es fühlte sich wie Beschäftigungstherapie an. Aus meiner Sicht gibt es einfach stärkere JR…

**P1 · 밸런스·게임플레이** — 베테랑 플레이어 비중 75%
> Trails in the Sky is the first entry in Falcom’s beloved turn-based RPG series. The story follows siblings (and eventual lovers) Estelle and Joshua Bright as they begin their journey as junior bracers, inspired by their legendary father Cassius Bright. The narrative is a slow bur…
> Putting aside the ridiculous naming choices and weird dialog along with very questionable choices in the protagonist siblings. I will say sometimes it's funny and the game sure has it's moments. I put all that to the side and kept up with it bc it the combat was interesting until…

**P1 · 그래픽·사운드** — 베테랑 플레이어 비중 33%
> Trails in the Sky is the first entry in Falcom’s beloved turn-based RPG series. The story follows siblings (and eventual lovers) Estelle and Joshua Bright as they begin their journey as junior bracers, inspired by their legendary father Cassius Bright. The narrative is a slow bur…
> A million words were spoken, yet nothing was said. Overly verbose, grating english voice acting (in parts, especially the main character), and a non-existant story that was praised by many here in the reviews. I'm not really sure we all played the same game. The graphics are lack…

※ 이 표는 Jira/Linear 임포트용 CSV로도 제공됩니다 (대시보드 → 액션 CSV).

## 방법론

- 데이터: Steam 공개 리뷰 (appreviews 엔드포인트, 증분 수집)
- 감성/토픽: Claude 분석기 또는 휴리스틱 폴백, analyzer_version으로 추적
- 액션 우선순위: 부정 언급 볼륨 × 신뢰도 가중(플레이타임 로그 스케일) × 최근성(반감기 45일)
- 작성자 정보는 수집 시 가명처리되며 본 리포트에 포함되지 않음
- 발췌는 저작권 고려로 280자 이내로 제한, 원본 링크 제공