# Player Voice Audit — Hollow Knight: Silksong

생성일: 2026-08-09 · 대상 기간: 2025-09-04 ~ 2026-08-09

## 개요

- 게임: **Hollow Knight: Silksong** (Team Cherry) · Steam appid 1030300
- Steam 전체 평가: **Very Positive** (긍정 373394 / 부정 44299 / 전체 417693)
- 분석 수집분: 리뷰 677건, 부정 74건 (11%)

## 감성 트렌드

- 최근 30일 평균 감성: **0.49** (−1 ~ +1)
- 이전 기간 대비: -0.06 (악화)

## 토픽별 감성

| 토픽 | 언급 수 | 부정 언급 | 부정률 |
|---|---:|---:|---:|
| 기타 | 590 | 61 | 10% |
| 그래픽·사운드 | 34 | 5 | 15% |
| 콘텐츠 분량 | 30 | 1 | 3% |
| 스토리·서사 | 28 | 4 | 14% |
| 난이도 | 20 | 7 | 35% |
| 버그·안정성 | 11 | 11 | 100% |
| 밸런스·게임플레이 | 7 | 3 | 43% |
| UI·UX | 5 | 1 | 20% |

## 언어 분포

- english: 240건 (35%)
- schinese: 159건 (23%)
- russian: 81건 (12%)
- spanish: 64건 (9%)
- brazilian: 40건 (6%)
- latam: 17건 (3%)
- french: 15건 (2%)
- turkish: 14건 (2%)
- koreana: 8건 (1%)
- german: 8건 (1%)

## 이상 이벤트 (부정 리뷰 스파이크)

- **2026-08-05**: 부정 리뷰 12건
- **2026-08-06**: 부정 리뷰 12건
- **2026-08-07**: 부정 리뷰 13건
- **2026-08-08**: 부정 리뷰 20건

## 대표 부정 피드백 발췌

**기타** (schinese, 2026-08-09)
> 我日你的樱桃社，地图恶意大就算了一堆屎一样贱的粪怪，md体积稍微大一点就二伤，神不神鬼不鬼的后撤步，打完1代有基础过来玩都恶心的要死不知道这个游戏设计起来是不是根本没想吸引新玩家，估计是故意的设计成这样，气得我飞升然后证明中国人能飞。我日你的

**스토리·서사** (english, 2026-08-09)
> I recently started Nine Sols again. Fir some reason I took a break in that game and in Silk Song fairly towards the end of the game. When I continued with Nine Sols I was surprised how fast I was able to get back in, I think I was even better at it now. I beat the last boss with…

**밸런스·게임플레이** (ukrainian, 2026-08-08)
> boring grind game

**그래픽·사운드** (english, 2026-08-08)
> I've been waiting for this game. Really have. I've been among the ones to buy it in the first hours within release. And I really, REALLY wanted to like it. But I just can't force myself to. The areas are interesting visually, the music is beautiful. But almost everything regardi…

**멀티플레이·네트워크** (english, 2026-08-08)
> I spent over 100 hours playing the Hollow Knight. The level design was incredibly fun, and the combat felt smooth and responsive. However, Siklsong just doesn't feel as smooth to control as Hollow Knight. Regular enemies feel strangely overtuned, many areas are filled with unnec…

원본 리뷰: https://steamcommunity.com/app/1030300/reviews/

## 우선 대응 권고 (액션 아이템)

신뢰도 가중(리뷰 작성 시점 플레이타임)과 최근성을 반영한 우선순위입니다.

| 우선순위 | 영역 | 부정 언급 | 20시간+ 플레이어 | 최근 30일 | 점수 |
|---|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| P0 | 버그·안정성 | 11건 | 64% | 91% | 16.7 |
| P0 | 난이도 | 7건 | 86% | 100% | 12 |
| P1 | 그래픽·사운드 | 5건 | 100% | 100% | 9 |
| P1 | 스토리·서사 | 4건 | 100% | 100% | 7.2 |
| P1 | 밸런스·게임플레이 | 3건 | 100% | 100% | 5.4 |

**P0 · 버그·안정성** — 베테랑 플레이어 비중 64%
> This game kept my mind occupied while I was couch-bound with a broken ankle. From the opening moments it was clear this was a special game, and I'd honestly happily buy it at twice the price for the amount of enjoyment I got from it.
> Amazing but so meny bugs

**P0 · 난이도** — 베테랑 플레이어 비중 86%
> I loved HK and I enjoy playing as hornet. But in an effort to outdo themselves from the original, they have landed on tedium. The game does not have the exploration and adventure like charm tied alongside the difficulty and boss fights from the original.
> pointless difficulty. i finished the game but at least put a difficulty option.

**P1 · 그래픽·사운드** — 베테랑 플레이어 비중 100%
> This game is like having a second job. Such a waste for all the great artwork, music and mechanics what do they matter if the game was made to be another problem in life?... After this I am not playing another hollow knight. Really a shame, it could have been such a nice game. Th…
> I really wanted to like Silksong but the game wont let you have a moment of fun. I played HK a few years ago and i enjoyed it very much just like other metro/souls games so i came in with high hopes. Don't get me wrong, the game is worth the money, even full price, it has tons of…

※ 이 표는 Jira/Linear 임포트용 CSV로도 제공됩니다 (대시보드 → 액션 CSV).

## 방법론

- 데이터: Steam 공개 리뷰 (appreviews 엔드포인트, 증분 수집)
- 감성/토픽: Claude 분석기 또는 휴리스틱 폴백, analyzer_version으로 추적
- 액션 우선순위: 부정 언급 볼륨 × 신뢰도 가중(플레이타임 로그 스케일) × 최근성(반감기 45일)
- 작성자 정보는 수집 시 가명처리되며 본 리포트에 포함되지 않음
- 발췌는 저작권 고려로 280자 이내로 제한, 원본 링크 제공